In his years at East High School in Cheyenne, Wyo., Tevis Bartlett was an elite athlete. So good, in fact, that he had multiple college scholarship offers by the time he graduated in 2015.
But before he could choose a school to attend, he first had to decide on a sport.
During football season, Bartlett was an outstanding two-way player. A quarterback on offense, he threw for 4,112 yards and 34 touchdowns in his high school career, while rushing for 3,613 yards and another 46 touchdowns. He even played a little wide receiver, which allowed him to score three more TDs through the air. Bartlett was also a defensive back, and played well enough to be a three-time all-state selection, just as he was on offense.
But in the winter Bartlett was a wrestler, and he was no less exceptional on the mat than on the football field. He ended up with four state individual championships, and he even claimed some national championships in both freestyle and Greco-Roman wrestling.
Drawn by his obvious talent, a lot of schools were recruiting Bartlett for either football or wrestling. Some schools had recruiters for both sports pursuing him. And at least one – the University of Wyoming in Laramie, just a short jaunt down I-80 from Cheyenne – wanted him to be both a football player and a wrestler.
Among the schools wanting him for wrestling were Oregon State, Stanford and Arizona State from the Pacific-12 Conference. Another school, Old Dominion in Norfolk, Va., even offered Bartlett (who had a 4.0 high school GPA) the equivalent of a full scholarship – one-half for wrestling and one-half for academics.
“For a long time I was getting heavily recruited for both football and wrestling,” Bartlett said. “It was probably the summer going into my senior year that I finally decided, ‘You know, I want to play football in college.’ I love both sports, and they’ve both taught me a ton about being an athlete and about life in general. But football was a little bit more of a calling for me.”